Whereas that original patch (since reversed) addressed
some symptoms related to manually edited config files,
this solution deals with root causes. And it goes much
beyond any single top field by protecting all of top's
fields. Henceforth, a duplicated field is not allowed.
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0114-top-Prevent-buffer-overflow-in-calibrate_fields.patch
commit c424a64331
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
Here, again, we have an example of attacking a problem
by addressing the symptoms. And that assertion made in
the original commit message is true if only if someone
had manually (maliciously) edited the top config file.
So let's reverse the original patch & thus prepare for
a proper solution addressing the cause, not a symptom.
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0114-top-Prevent-buffer-overflow-in-calibrate_fields.patch
commit c424a64331
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
The whole idea was to make top's 'scat' function small
and very quick, unlike that standard 'strcat' routine.
To achieve that end we ignore the potential for buffer
overruns and trust callers to provide adequate dest's.
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0109-top-Protect-scat-from-buffer-overflows.patch
commit 9c745975b2
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
This is as far as we need go with respect to the issue
of integer overflow addressed in that reference below.
That patch, of course, was reversed to prepare for us.
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0105-top-Prevent-integer-overflows-in-procs_refresh.patch
commit 131e5e2fe6
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
That patch referenced below is being reverted because:
. By design, no other top macro looks like a function.
Instead, they all contain some minimal capitalization.
The 'grow_by_size' macro stands out like a sore thumb.
. We would need to approach 400+ million tasks for for
the 1st addressed problem to produce integer overflow.
. And a 2nd check against SSIZE_MAX remains a mystery.
Me thinks a system on which top is running will suffer
ENOMEM before we need to worry about integer overflow.
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0105-top-Prevent-integer-overflows-in-procs_refresh.patch
commit 131e5e2fe6
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
Rather than validate the window's 'sortindx' each time
it was referenced (as was done in the patch below), we
now ensure the validity just once when the config file
is read. Thereafter, a running top will police bounds.
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0102-top-Check-sortindx.patch
commit d5b8ac7139
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
Here's yet another example of dealing with a potential
problem at the symptom level, instead of addressing it
at the source. So, we will reverse that original patch
referenced below in preparation for a proper solution.
[ at the least, this ugly code should have used that ]
[ existing MAXTBL macro, making it a little prettier ]
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0102-top-Check-sortindx.patch
commit d5b8ac7139
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
This patch replaces an original patch referenced below
which has now been reversed. We now validate variables
'graph_cpus', 'graph_mems' and 'summ_mscale' just once
at startup. Thereafter, top enforces the proper range.
[ we afford the same treatment to that 'task_mscale' ]
[ variable, which was ignored in the original patch. ]
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0099-top-Check-graph_cpus-graph_mems-and-summ_mscale.patch
commit cd8ba5670e
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
The variables graph_cpus, graph_mems & summ_mscale are
all well managed in a running top. They were, however,
each vulnerable to tampering via the rcfile. So rather
than continually addressing the symptoms, we'll attack
the root cause just once at startup in the next patch.
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0099-top-Check-graph_cpus-graph_mems-and-summ_mscale.patch
commit cd8ba5670e
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
While it's only documented (so far) in commit text and
an occasional email I've tried to maintain some coding
standards primarily for reference/navigation purposes.
They also served, I felt, as useful mental challenges.
Someday I will get around to formerly documenting them
but in the meantime here are the ones for this commit:
. functions are grouped into logical (i hope) sections
. functions & sections are ordered to avoid prototypes
. function names are alphabetical within every section
. all functions & sections must be referenced in top.h
This patch just attempts to honor the above standards,
while also covering this new behavior in the man page.
[ please note that the net result of these 2 patches ]
[ is simply to avoid pathname truncations should our ]
[ limit of 1024 be exceeded. they do not have a role ]
[ in solving the 'local privilege escalation' issue. ]
[ and we can never prevent a user from setting their ]
[ HOME var to a directory writable by some attacker! ]
[ the only real protection for that CVE-2018-1122 is ]
[ those soon to be enhanced rcfile integrity checks, ]
[ achieved through several of the following patches. ]
Reference(s):
. original qualys patch
0097-top-Do-not-default-to-the-cwd-in-configs_read.patch
commit b45c4803dd
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
This patch prevents three problems:
1/ Because snprintf() returns "the number of characters (excluding the
terminating null byte) which would have been written to the final string
if enough space had been available", _eol may point past the end of _str
and write out-of-bounds (in Batch mode).
2/ _eol is never checked against _str, so "while (*(--_eol) == ' ');"
may point _eol below _str and write out-of-bounds (in Batch mode).
3/ Sanity-check Pseudo_row to protect the strcpy().
This patch fixes two problems:
1/ In the switch case 0, if sub_end is at the very end of lin[], the two
null-byte writes are off-by-two (a stack-based buffer overflow). Replace
this end-of-string "emulation" with an equivalent test on ch (and then
goto/break out of the loop).
2/ "sub_end += 2" jumps over the null-byte terminator in lin[] if the
line contains a raw (without a tilde) \001-\010 character. Detect such a
null-byte terminator and goto/break out of the loop.
Note: in the case of a raw \001-\010 character, the character at
"sub_end + 1" is never processed (it is skipped/jumped over); this is
not a security problem anymore (since 2/ was fixed), so we decided not
to change this behavior, for backward-compatibility.
- Make sure i is at least 1 before "i - 1" and "--i".
- Initialize endpflg (to 0, as it was originally, since it is static)
before the "for" loop (the "break" may leave endpflg uninitialized,
for example).
pflgsall[] can contain PFLAGSSIZ = 100 elements, each iteration of the
loop can write 3 elements to pflgsall[], and there are EU_MAXPFLGS = 58
iterations: a buffer overflow (it can be triggered via the configuration
file, for example, by filling "fieldscur" with the "sortindx" flag).
The safety of the critical function task_show() depends on the sanity of
Screen_cols. Just copy the tests on w_cols to Screen_cols (from the same
function adj_geometry()).
Several of these buffer overflows can actually be triggered (through the
configuration file for example): in config_file(), inspection_utility(),
and show_special().
The default action for SIGURG is to ignore the signal, for example.
This is very similar to the patch "ps/display.c: Always exit from
signal_handler()."
Every time sortindx is used as an index, or loaded from the
configuration file. Otherwise it leads to out-of-bounds reads and
arbitrary code execution.
Otherwise they may lead to out-of-bounds writes (snprintf() returns the
number of characters which would have been written if enough space had
been available).
Also, make sure buf is null-terminated after COLPLUSCH has been written.
Otherwise they lead to out-of-bounds reads and format-string bugs.
Since these variables are set/written to in several places (for example,
config_file()), check them in the only place where they are read/used.
Also, constify the static gtab[]s.
If the HOME environment variable is not set, or not absolute, use the
home directory returned by getpwuid(getuid()), if set and absolute
(instead of the cwd "."); otherwise, set p_home to NULL.
To keep the changes to a minimum, we rely on POSIX, which requires that
fopen() fails with ENOENT if the pathname (Rc_name) is an empty string.
This integrates well into the existing code, and makes write_rcfile()
work without a change.
Also, it makes the code in configs_read() easier to follow: only set and
use p_home if safe, and only set Rc_name if safe (in all the other cases
it is the empty string, and the fopen() calls fail). Plus, check for
snprintf() truncation (and if it happens, reset Rc_name to the empty
string).
Important note: top.1 should probably be updated, since it mentions the
fallback to the current working directory.
With a little luck, this should be the final tweak for
our support of extra wide characters. Currently, those
characters don't always display the '+' indicator when
they've been truncated. Now, it should always be seen.
[ plus it's done a tad more efficiently via snprintf ]
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
As it turns out, that Ukrainian 'demo' text supporting
the '=' command was 152 bytes long, up from an English
version of 80 bytes. Unfortunately, the buffer used to
format all such strings was insufficient at 128 bytes.
Depending on the width of one's terminal, some strange
result could be experienced when a multi-byte sequence
was truncated. So, this just makes that buffer bigger.
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
After wrestling with extra wide characters, supporting
languages like zh_CN, sometimes default/minimum column
widths might force a truncation of translated headers.
So, this commit explores one way that such truncations
could be avoided. It is designed so as to have minimal
impact on existing code, ultimately affecting just one
function. But it's off by default via its own #define.
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
When I recently added extra wide character support for
locales like zh_CN, I didn't worry about some overhead
associated with the new calls to 'mbtowc' & 'wcwidth'.
That's because such overhead was usually incurred with
user interactions, not a normal iterative top display.
There was, however, one area where this overhead would
impact the normal iterative top mode - that's with the
Summary display. So I peeked at the glibc source code.
As it turns out, the costs of executing those 'mbtowc'
and 'wcwidth' functions were not at all insignificant.
So, this patch will avoid them in the vast majority of
instances, while still enabling extra wide characters.
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
There is (should be) no justification for changing the
width of the percentage columns (%CPU, %MEM) depending
on the BOOST_PERCNT #define. So this patch will ensure
that both columns are fixed at their former maximum 5.
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
With the documentation update in the commit referenced
below, we should also account for such threads as they
will already be represented in the task/thread totals.
[ and do it in a way that might avoid future changes ]
Reference(s):
commit a238a687ce
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
Back when top was refactored to support UTF-8 encoding
it was acknowledged that languages like zh_CN were not
supported. That was because a single 'character' might
require more than a single 'column' when it's printed.
Well I've now figured out how to accommodate languages
like that. My adaptation is represented in this patch.
[ and just in case someone wishes to avoid the extra ]
[ runtime costs, a #define OFF_XTRAWIDE is included. ]
Along the way, I've cleaned up some miscellaneous code
supporting the 'Inspect' feature so that the rightmost
screen column was always used rather than being blank.
[ interestingly, my xterm & urxvt terminal emulators ]
[ are able to split extra wide characters then print ]
[ 1/2 of such graphics in the last column. the gnome ]
[ terminal emulator does not duplicate such behavior ]
[ but prints 1 extra character in same width window. ]
Reference(s):
. Sep, 2017 - original utf8 support
commit 7ef38420a4
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
When the new approach for startup defaults was adopted
in the reference below, a file might be left open that
technically should be closed. This situation arises in
the unlikely event the #define RCFILE_NOERR is active.
Without that #define, the program will exit early thus
rendering the open file issue moot. However, even with
that #define there was no real harm with an open file.
It simply meant a 2nd FILE struct would have been used
when, or if, the rcfile was written via a 'W' command.
Anyway, this patch ensures such a file will be closed.
Reference(s):
. Dec, 2017 - /etc/topdefaultrc introduced
commit 3e6a208ae5
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
Those references below offer more detail regarding the
default startup changes beginning with version 3.3.10.
It is important to remember that all such changes were
supposed to impact only new users or users who had not
saved the personal config file (via that 'W' command).
However, I introduced a bug wherein the rcfile was not
fully honored. This gave the changes a bad reputation.
That bug was corrected in release 3.3.11 but the issue
of default startup options keeps resurfacing. And it's
clear there's no consensus on what should be included.
Our --disable-modern-top configure option is of little
help since it remains an all-or-nothing approach. What
we need is an answer offering unlimited customization.
So, this commit will provide distribution packagers or
system administrators with a much more flexible way to
set their own preferred startup default configuration.
A new rcfile is being introduced: '/etc/topdefaultrc',
whose format/content is the same as a personal rcfile.
Thus once a 'proper' enterprise configuration has been
established and saved via 'W', it can be copied to the
/etc/ directory. Thereafter, startup in the absence of
a saved rcfile will use that configuration as default.
Now if a distribution packager or system administrator
wishes to expose their users to some of top's advanced
capabilities they can do so gradually. Perhaps setting
up graph mode for summary area task and memory display
while retaining the %CPU sort could be tried. Or maybe
showing colors, but better customized for a particular
terminal emulator. Such possibilities are now endless.
[ in exploiting this new capability, i hope that the ]
[ other windows (alt display mode) aren't overlooked ]
Reference(s):
. Sep, 2014 - Not fully honoring rcfile bug discussed
https://www.freelists.org/post/procps/top-saved-rcfile-bug
. Oct, 2014 - Attempt to defend new startup defaults
https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1153049
. Jul, 2015 - Forest vs. %CPU views discussion
https://gitlab.com/procps-ng/procps/issues/6
. Oct, 2017 - Question the use of --disable-modern-top
https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1499410
. Oct, 2017 - Forest vs. %CPU views discussion again
https://www.freelists.org/post/procps/Forest-mode-by-default-in-top-seems-a-bit-strange
. Dec, 2017 - Rehash of 3.3.10 startup defaults change
https://gitlab.com/procps-ng/procps/issues/78
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
Way back in November of 2011, the library was equipped
with an overridable error message handler function. It
was done expressly for a program like top which alters
the tty. But that support was withdrawn shortly after.
This was all done in the lead up to v3.3.2. That's the
release where NLS support was added and it represented
a hectic time. In hindsight, the changes went too far.
So this commit, in a minimal fashion, restores ability
to address a potential fatal library error. After all,
any properly behaving library would never unilaterally
subject a caller to a stderr message and then an exit.
[ when exposing 1 variable in libprocps.sym, 2 other ]
[ existing symbols were repositioned alphabetically. ]
Reference(s):
. generalized library memory provisions
commit 7126cc4491
. top exploit library memory provisions
commit 88087ec5a5
. library xalloc type functions made private
commit 2865ded64e
. restored prior top memory logic
commit 05f5deb97c
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
After noticing that the 'uk' translation expanded what
was supposed to be a 3 line header into 5 lines, seems
appropriate to offer more guidance on max lines count.
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
And I thought those strange characters I saw with only
certain translations in Fields Management descriptions
were resulting from my terminal emulator deficiencies.
Turns out that ol' top wasn't addressing possibilities
of such descriptions ending with multi-byte sequences.
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
Initially, I was going to ignore that coverity warning
CID #177876. But, since top may be running SETUID it's
best if it can be avoided instead. The fix was simple.
We'll trade the access() call for a real fopen() call.
This time-of-check-time-of-use warning should go away.
------------------------------------------------------
When XDG support was originally introduced in top, the
author made a poor choice in access(). A real question
that needed asking was 'does the file exist'. However,
the question that was asked was 'can this real user ID
or this real group ID access the file'. Then, when the
fopen() is finally issued, top would use the effective
user ID or the effective group ID to access that file.
That's what opened the potential TOCTOU vulnerability,
which was important only if top was running SUID/SGID.
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
By eliminating the call to 'fmtmk', the 'utf8_justify'
function could more easily be used in libproc someday.
Signed-off-by: Jim Warner <james.warner@comcast.net>
